some UDP trackers cant establish connection with ssh proxy

it doesnt really matter that much, as I also run the VPN, so my IP Is still protected without the proxy. but I figured bringing this up would be useful to see if it was just an incompatibility with the proxy or some other issue.

but I DO run the proxy as a second line of defense generally, and I've noticed that some UDP trackers (RARBG is one) can't establish connection, but ONLY when the socks5 proxy is used.

if I go and disable the proxy in the settings it connects blazingly fast -- showing that it is NOT the VPN IP being blocked. it is specifically the proxy failing to connect to these addresses.

DHT works fine, and IK http trackers work fine. there may or may not be some udp trackers that do work, I will have to test more to figure this out -- but I do know a wide swath of torrents, specifically with udp trackers, dont connect well and only use DHT. now I have become aware it is the proxy at cause, not the servers being down (most times).

I checked firewall settings (even disabled all firewall and malware blocking) and found that it truly was the proxy causing the connection failure after messing around a bit to see what really caused it.

this may just be a limitation of the proxy -- I was reading somewhere that there needs to be some kind of 'dante' socks5 protocol or something for udp trackers to be truly supported via proxy -- but this may be BS,

so for now, I have the proxy disabled and use the killswitch, which should still be enough for privacy. Like I said, its not a huge deal as long as the VPN can connect to stuff, and a proxy alone isnt enough for privacy anyway...

Comments

  • Hello!

    What you're currently using with just the VPN and the Kill Switch should provide you all the protection you need, but for investigating the SOCKS5 Proxy I'd have to suggest emailing [email protected] with what you're seeing so that they can try to replicate the issue and verify whether it's an issue with the whole SOCKS5 region, or specific IPs within it. Our agents will be able to get back to you with possible steps to try and information to provide while they attempt to track down the cause!
  • Thank you for addressing this issue.  I've had this problem for over two years with my utorrent client being unable to connect to UDP torrent trackers.  I've been going crazy trying to find out how to connect and had basically given up.  I'm using utorrent 2.2.1.  I've never used the proxy on utorrent, so I don't think the first post's info is going to help me.  I've tried both TCP and UDP connections with the PIA VPN but neither one makes a difference.  Any other advice?
  • I dont know -- everything seems to connect for me on toronto servers as long as the proxy isnt enabled. I tested it again today -- I am sorry for not being able to help any more...

    some, like exodus.desync are just down -- I dont generally have problems with public trackers -- if its private your into, then that may be the problem too -- many block VPNs
  • edited August 2015
    Thanks for the reply.  I'm only talking about public trackers.  I can never seem to connect to seeders from udp://open.demonii.com:1337 - There are usually at least one seeder listed, and the status of the tracker is always "working".  I'm using utorrent 2.2.1.  I can always connect if there is a DHT or Peer Exchange seeder, but I'm totally out of luck if its on udp.  Any ideas?  I also tried going through Toronto but no success either. 
  • I have the same issue with the following server locations: California and Silicon Valley. The only other server I use is West(AZ) which is able to connect to the rarbg tracker.
  • Trying once again to bump this topic.  Nothing really has changed on my end.  I still have problems connecting to any udp tracker seeders using utorrent 2.2.1  I have tried using port forwarding through Toronto Canada and input the corresponding port number into utorrent, but still not connecting to udp seeds.  The bottom right network icon on utorrent is green, so that seems to be ok and as I said before, udp tracker status is "working".  Any other ideas of what I can do?
  • Doesn't seem as though this issue will ever be addressed. I've been searching forums for months, and there is no solution, and it seems no one wants to even discuss the issue on the torrent client sites I've been to. VPN is well and good, but the nice thing about using the proxy is if you leave the computer and you get disconnected from the VPN, uTorrent will halt all traffic, but without using VPN traffic continues unprotected.

    I have also noticed another issue that seems to be occurring with increasing frequency. On some torrents I get drastically improved performance with proxy enabled. Turn off the proxy, and my speed drops to roughly 10% or even more. Unfortunately the best tracker seems to be UDP only. So if the torrent is only on that tracker, I can't get decent throughput. Nothing more annoying than seeing 20 seeds, but only getting 20k download speeds. 

    I really wish this issue would get some attention.
Sign In or Register to comment.