New Feature Request: Pause VPN

This might sound like a bit of a stupid feature request, but how about baking in the ability to pause VPN for a short period of time, like a minute, two minutes, five minutes, etc.?

I suggest this because no matter what, sometimes you cannot get to a website at all through PIA VPN because it is blocked, but you still need to get through anyway, e.g., buying baseball tickets on the team's website.

I mention pausing the VPN because, sometimes, I turn it off to go to the site, then I forget to re-engage it, and then I spend a lot of time, sometimes hours, surfing around until I realize I'd forgotten to re-engage PIA.

If this is not a good idea, or someone else has a better suggestion, please post.

Comments

  • Sounds like an interesting feature to have! I've passed on the suggestion to the dev team. Thank you!
  • edited April 2018
    Aside from all the other multitudinous problems I've had with PIA in the past several years, what the OP brings up here is a major contributing factor behind why I rarely ever use PIA anymore, and why I went with another provider.

    In my view it's ridiculous that, with PIA, I can't whitelist a few urls (banking, paying my AT&T wireless bill, Craigslist, etc.) that won't accept connections from vpns that are known to have abusive subscribers (PIA unfortunately being rather high profile that way). If I forget to disconnect from PIA before attempting to login to my bank account I'm immediately hit with a list of security questions which I must successfully answer or risk being locked out of my account (and it's happened to me more than once -- talk about a great way to ruin your day). I and many other PIA customers have asked for it many times in the past several years -- it's called "bypass" or "routing." But like so many other requests it's just been ignored or dismissed entirely with some "It's not technically feasible" excuses.

    Recently Max-P gave what, on the surface appears to be, a credible reason for why PIA can't do it. At least he stepped up to the plate and responded, which is far more than I can say for so many others. Yet oddly enough there are several vpn providers who include routing as a standard feature in their apps. One of them provides it an open source app which can, therefore, be audited (and apparently has been) to validate that it doesn't have any of the problems that Max-P hypothesizes.

    I'd be the last person to call Max-P a liar. So believing he is telling the truth one can only conclude that, while it's technically feasible for a few other vpn providers to selectively bypass specific urls, with PIA it's not technically feasible, which evidently is due to their own inherent technological shortcomings.

    Those who, like me, consider selective routing an indispensable feature will have to, as I have, look elsewhere.
  • edited April 2018
    @tomeworm Do you have any examples of providers that do have policy based routing, especially the open-source app that does it?

    I already explained everything I know in the post you linked, so I'm thinking either they really made an amazing job and I'm really curious to see how they pulled that off or they just do the DNS thing which works but is dangerously unreliable and not something PIA would adopt.
  • Pausing should be as simple as having it do a disconnect with a timer, then reconnect when timer ends.
  • Max-P said:
    @tomeworm Do you have any examples of providers that do have policy based routing, especially the open-source app that does it?

    I already explained everything I know in the post you linked, so I'm thinking either they really made an amazing job and I'm really curious to see how they pulled that off or they just do the DNS thing which works but is dangerously unreliable and not something PIA would adopt.
    Sure. AirVPN. If it's really as dangerous as you assume it to be then I'd welcome hearing some specifics about that. I'll then take up your concerns with them and see what they have to say. They're not at all sensitive about criticism, constructive or otherwise.
  • BTW @Max-P you like anyone else can get a free 3 day trial of AirVPN (no credit card required). Hopefully that would give you enough time to evaluate it to determine if Eddie's routing feature is flawed. Go to the Contact page and under Department select Trial Request. Leave an email address and they'll set up a trial account for you.
  • edited May 2018
    @Max-P did you ever follow up on this? I'm still desirous of knowing if you've identified any security flaws, routing or otherwise, with AirVPN.
  • edited June 2018
    As it turns out, during the past month or so, all of a sudden, I am all of a sudden unable to send email through my Gmail accounts when using Outlook 365. I never, ever had that problem even once before. Now it's practically an all the time problem. And when I finally find an IP address of PIA's that I can still send email out through, before I disconnect from that PIA IP address, it gets blocked, too! So either Gmail is really smart and quick, or PIA themselves are causing the block (for whatever reason).

    So, if PIA were ever to do the OP's feature, I would add an option to pause for 10 seconds, or 15 or 30 seconds, just so I can send my emails and then quickly reconnect automatically.

    (P.S.: I have been offered the email whitelisting option, but that's got limited appeal to me since I funnel seven different Gmail addresses, all of which have a specific purpose, through my Outlook. So please do not suggest that in a reply.)
  • @zamakli

    Thank you for the suggestions! I would recommend also submitting them here, this will go straight to our team for review.
  • I'd LOVE to be able to bypass VPN for some apps to (like Outlook) - I *constantly* get blocked by it when I switch servers :(  It detects a change in location and activates "security features" - a ROYAL pain.
Sign In or Register to comment.